Owner blames Ofsted for closure of nursery


Ofsted has been accused of causing the closure of Winchcombe Farm Day Nursery in Warwickshire. Steve Taylor, who owns the setting, had to make the difficult decision to close the business on the 22nd December, with all 24 staff being made redundant.

Steve stated that the nursery has been struggling for some time and the latest Ofsted report, which rated the nursery as ‘requires improvement’, was the last straw.

Hugely increased running costs and decreased funding have all affected the business over time, with the owner putting in thousands of pounds each month to try and keep the nursery going.

The Ofsted report described how the teachers should better use assessment to plan activities and that staff do not fully support children’s understanding of families and traditions beyond their own experiences.

There were positives from the Ofsted report, such as the training of staff and pupil’s knowledge of the natural world.

In a letter that Steve sent to parents, he disputed some of the points in the Ofsted report such as their criticism of children using knives and forks to eat mashed potato, rather than a spoon.

The nursery previously had a rating of ‘good’.

In the letter, Steve states: “We know that a ‘requires improvement’ rating will severely impact on new parents choosing to visit the nursery in the New Year and is therefore effectively a commercial death sentence. This was pointed out to the Inspector at the time of the inspection but she seemed singularly unimpressed and frankly couldn’t care less. It is difficult to express my anger at the attitude taken by the inspector and the ineptitude of government departments across the board.”

Steve also stated: “It’s devastating that one person’s opinion can cause such horrendous damage. This inspection was triggered because we are planning to convert two outdoor classrooms, about 100 meters from the main building, into holiday lets and someone queried whether there could be a safeguarding issue with this. As soon as the word safeguarding was mentioned they sent their hit squad, and they said that because we have not had an inspection in a while, they would carry out an on-the-spot inspection of the whole school. Usually, you get notice of such an inspection, we had none.

“In the feedback session at the end, the inspector said the nursery was too white and middle class, saying our diversity policy wasn’t up to scratch. We presented lots of evidence and explained how we celebrate events like Chinese New Year, Eid and Australia day at the school, but she just wouldn’t listen.

“When we found out the result I phoned Ofsted and told them that a rating of requires improvement was a death sentence to a rural nursery like ours, but they just couldn’t understand it at all. If you were a parent and you looked on your iPhone, you would immediately be put off by that.

“We had 30 staff in the summer and 24 remaining who lost their jobs on 22nd December. This inspection along with the Government’s 30 hours free childcare policy has led to 30 people here going on the dole.

“This closure is a shock to staff and to parents, who can see we are a good nursery. Ofsted don’t see that they just tick a box. It’s horrible for the staff, parents, children and to me, it feels like I have wasted 15 years and hundreds of thousands of pounds.”

Steve added that parents were being supported in finding childcare for their children elsewhere and some former members of staff will be acting as nannies.

Before its closure, 59 children attended the nursery. Parents have now taken to social media to express their sadness about the nursery closing.

Stacey Newton wrote: “I couldn’t be more upset reading this. As a past employee I cannot praise the setting higher.

“Having recently visited with my own daughter, my husband and I couldn’t be more certain in the decision to send our daughter there having watched it grow into an even more exceptional place.

“This setting has been a huge part of many people’s lives and the hard work and dedication of staff past, present and founders is one of passion and sheer focus on the development of the children!

“I can only express shock and sadness and know that decisions are not always in the hands of those we wish they were.

“Thank you Winchcombe for being a place where I grew, life long friendships grew, children grew and know that there is an army of people who are feeling the devastation alongside you.”

Tony King added: “Genuinely saddened and disgusted to hear this news.

“But please be proud that you and the team created a faultless environment for our children and you set them on a great path for which we will always be grateful.”



2 thoughts on “Owner blames Ofsted for closure of nursery

  • January 3, 2018 at 6:55 pm

    If the situation is as reported then This is unforgivable and would attract legal action for damages in any other sector.
    Nobody is listening, despite numerous warnings, to the fact that if you wanted to purposely damage the sector you could not do a better job. There is enough ‘smoke’ now to suggest there is a fire and if Government still see themselves as leaders in supporting children and families they should do something now. The situation outlined by Mr Taylor is an experience that many nurseries are currently struggling with.
    I sometimes wonder if there isn’t an alternative agenda, to suggest that a Nursery is too white and middle class is in itself a discriminatory comment and one that Ofsted should be called upon to explain. If Ofsted came into being to improve educational standards then why are we performing at a lower level in comparison to Europe. Clearly meeting Ofsted standards and rigour does not seem to carry over to educational capability. It is time questions are asked of Ofsted. Who inspects the inspectors. There are very capable inspectors but too much is left to personal outlook and agenda.
    I hope that the individual who expressed their concerns about safeguarding issues is very pleased with themselves especially as most nurseries, including those in schools are much closer to potential threat of a safeguarding issue.
    The owner has my deepest sympathy (not that that will mean very much) and my hope is that the parents will not leave this situation rest.

  • January 3, 2018 at 3:33 pm

    Family’s and children loosing established key workers and friends ….. When oh when will we have transparency to the complaints procedures of Ofsted, and an inspection framework fit for purpose.
    Most settings are not in the financial position to challenge OFSTED, if you think your insurance covers it ,check the small print it wont.
    Most Early Years settings decide to close or change their manager after a judgment is deemed below Good ; guess what it close’s the window on the individuals reports and of cause raises OFSTED’s statistics that they would like to show .
    As Early Years managers much of our time is given to dealing with Local Government requiring Statistics in Portals , the time tapping away would be better served providing education and well planned programmes of development /education and supporting our staff in development.
    Please some one tell me in the EYFS where is the requirement to use a spoon for mash ? Surely this is based on a child’s individual development not an individual inspector on the day.

    Good Luck Steve and Team, if you have the energy and inclination stand up and let your voice be heard

    No wonder only one Nursery has ever been successful in their challenges to OFSTED



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *